Definitely the best selling in the Columbus area! Are they pricy...Wowzers yes! And in my opinion, not worth the price point. They are good, but they lack that depth of flavor that makes you crave more. That little extra that has folks asking for the recipe. The staff was super friendly! And is it better than others in Columbus- yes! Hands down. But still not knocking it out (for me). I had a small slice of each and none invited me back for more. I think the average person would rave - so I won't knock them for not ringing my bell!! $3 per buckeye seems too steep. Because I make them myself and always have folks salivating for more- I'm very picky and also know how much it costs to make them well.

Columbus, Ohio · Since 2020
The Buckeye
Lady.
Home of the Stuffed Buckeye!! Handcrafting Ohio's favorite peanut butter & chocolate confection — plus 75 rotating varieties of Stuffed Buckeyes™. Your one stop shop for the quintessential taste of Ohio.
75+
Varieties
100%
Handcrafted
Since 2020
Columbus, OH
Our Buckeyes
Handcrafted with love in Columbus, Ohio - one sweet little bite at a time.
How to Get Your Buckeyes
Just had a taste of the Buckeye Lady's original buckeyes yesterday at our band competition lunch and they were fabulous. I am not a fan of sweets, but they were the perfect treat and not overly sweet. Thank Buckeye Lady for making them on such a shirt notice, the kids really enjoyed the special treat before competition and brought back top marks at the Shoe later in the day! Go Irish!
This small business is incredible. The staff are so friendly, the buckeyes are hand made, they are the tastiest treat AND they support the best causes! They even helped with buckeyes for our Dublin Scioto Band. We LOVE them and had the best experience all around and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! 💚🤍💚🤍💚🤍
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
Definitely the best selling in the Columbus area! Are they pricy...Wowzers yes! And in my opinion, not worth the price point. They are good, but they lack that depth of flavor that makes you crave more. That little extra that has folks asking for the recipe. The staff was super friendly! And is it better than others in Columbus- yes! Hands down. But still not knocking it out (for me). I had a small slice of each and none invited me back for more. I think the average person would rave - so I won't knock them for not ringing my bell!! $3 per buckeye seems too steep. Because I make them myself and always have folks salivating for more- I'm very picky and also know how much it costs to make them well.
Just had a taste of the Buckeye Lady's original buckeyes yesterday at our band competition lunch and they were fabulous. I am not a fan of sweets, but they were the perfect treat and not overly sweet. Thank Buckeye Lady for making them on such a shirt notice, the kids really enjoyed the special treat before competition and brought back top marks at the Shoe later in the day! Go Irish!
This small business is incredible. The staff are so friendly, the buckeyes are hand made, they are the tastiest treat AND they support the best causes! They even helped with buckeyes for our Dublin Scioto Band. We LOVE them and had the best experience all around and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! 💚🤍💚🤍💚🤍
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
Definitely the best selling in the Columbus area! Are they pricy...Wowzers yes! And in my opinion, not worth the price point. They are good, but they lack that depth of flavor that makes you crave more. That little extra that has folks asking for the recipe. The staff was super friendly! And is it better than others in Columbus- yes! Hands down. But still not knocking it out (for me). I had a small slice of each and none invited me back for more. I think the average person would rave - so I won't knock them for not ringing my bell!! $3 per buckeye seems too steep. Because I make them myself and always have folks salivating for more- I'm very picky and also know how much it costs to make them well.
Just had a taste of the Buckeye Lady's original buckeyes yesterday at our band competition lunch and they were fabulous. I am not a fan of sweets, but they were the perfect treat and not overly sweet. Thank Buckeye Lady for making them on such a shirt notice, the kids really enjoyed the special treat before competition and brought back top marks at the Shoe later in the day! Go Irish!
This small business is incredible. The staff are so friendly, the buckeyes are hand made, they are the tastiest treat AND they support the best causes! They even helped with buckeyes for our Dublin Scioto Band. We LOVE them and had the best experience all around and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! 💚🤍💚🤍💚🤍
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
Definitely the best selling in the Columbus area! Are they pricy...Wowzers yes! And in my opinion, not worth the price point. They are good, but they lack that depth of flavor that makes you crave more. That little extra that has folks asking for the recipe. The staff was super friendly! And is it better than others in Columbus- yes! Hands down. But still not knocking it out (for me). I had a small slice of each and none invited me back for more. I think the average person would rave - so I won't knock them for not ringing my bell!! $3 per buckeye seems too steep. Because I make them myself and always have folks salivating for more- I'm very picky and also know how much it costs to make them well.
Just had a taste of the Buckeye Lady's original buckeyes yesterday at our band competition lunch and they were fabulous. I am not a fan of sweets, but they were the perfect treat and not overly sweet. Thank Buckeye Lady for making them on such a shirt notice, the kids really enjoyed the special treat before competition and brought back top marks at the Shoe later in the day! Go Irish!
This small business is incredible. The staff are so friendly, the buckeyes are hand made, they are the tastiest treat AND they support the best causes! They even helped with buckeyes for our Dublin Scioto Band. We LOVE them and had the best experience all around and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! 💚🤍💚🤍💚🤍
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
Buckeyes for
Every Occasion
Corporate events, weddings, birthdays, and more - pick your packs, choose your flavors, and we'll handle the rest.


Bring the
Buckeye Cart
A full cart rental setup with a server for 2 hours and umbrella, delivered right to your event - perfect for a premium presentation.
Make Your Own
Buckeyes
Gather your crew of 6-10 people and dive into the tips, tricks, and tastes of the Traditional Buckeye. Roll, dip, and take your creations home.
From $40 per person · Allow 24 to 48 hours for response

perfect for birthdays, showers,
bachelorettes & team outings!
Hours & Location
Our Location
4493 N High St
Columbus, Ohio 43214 · Clintonville
Store Hours
- Tuesday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Wednesday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Thursday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Friday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Saturday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Sunday
- 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM
- Monday
- 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM




