Question 1

How do I place an order?

Accepted Answer

Select your pack size, choose your flavors, and proceed through checkout. Pickup and local delivery are available.

Question 2

Do you ship?

Accepted Answer

We partner with Goldbelly for nationwide shipping. For Columbus-area customers, local delivery is available instead.

Question 3

How long do buckeyes stay fresh?

Accepted Answer

Buckeyes stay fresh for up to 2 weeks when stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

Question 4

What are buckeyes made of?

Accepted Answer

Our classic buckeyes are made with peanut butter, powdered sugar, butter, vanilla, and chocolate. Stuffed and specialty flavors include additional ingredients.

Question 5

Do you offer vegan options?

Accepted Answer

Yes! We offer 6 vegan flavors available year-round: Vegan Traditional, Vegan Bourbon, Vegan Cookies & Cream, Vegan PBJ, Vegan Puppy Chow, and Vegan White Chocolate.

Question 6

What is the delivery radius?

Accepted Answer

We deliver within 20 miles of our store at 4493 N High St, Columbus, OH. Delivery is available weekdays only.

Question 7

Are any flavors gluten-free?

Accepted Answer

Many of our flavors are gluten-free. Check the allergen page for a full breakdown of every flavor.

Question 8

What is the order deadline?

Accepted Answer

Orders must be placed by 12:00 PM to be fulfilled the next available day. Orders placed after 12 PM apply to the following business day.

Question 9

Do you use real chocolate?

Accepted Answer

Yes, we use high-quality chocolate for all of our buckeyes.

Question 10

Can buckeyes be frozen?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Buckeyes freeze well for up to 3 months. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before serving.

Question 11

Do you accommodate allergies?

Accepted Answer

All products are made in a shared kitchen that processes peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, soy, and wheat. Cross-contamination is possible. Please inform us of allergies at checkout.

Question 12

What are delivery fees?

Accepted Answer

Delivery within 10 miles is $25. Delivery between 10–20 miles is $50.

Question 13

Can I reorder a previous order?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Log in to your account and visit Order History to reorder any past configuration.

Frequently Asked Questions