Our Flavors

Baker's Choice

Can’t decide which flavor to try? Leave it to our bakers! With Baker’s Choice, our team will handpick a delicious flavor for you from our available varieties- it’s a sweet surprise every time!

Banana Cream

Stuffed with banana cream, topped with a dried banana chip

Black Raspberry Chip Cheesecake

Stuffed with black raspberry chip cheesecake, topped with chocolate chip. ft. The Cheesecake Girl

Bourbon

Bourbon flavored dough, contains alcohol

Butterfinger

Stuffed and topped with Butterfinger bits

Butterscotch

Stuffed and topped with butterscotch chips

Candy Cane Buttercream

Stuffed with peppermint candy cane buttercream and topped with crushed candy cane

Carrot Cake

Stuffed with carrot cake and topped with cream cheese frosting

Chai Spice

Stuffed with chai spice ganache and topped with cinnamon, sugar, and cardamom sprinkle

Chocolate Candies

Stuffed and topped with M&M® candies

Cinnamon Roll

Stuffed with cinnamon roll ganache and topped with cinnamon sugar

Coconut Almond

Stuffed with coconut almond mixture and an almond, topped with toasted coconut

Cold Brew Cream

Stuffed with coffee cream, topped with espresso cookies

Cookie Butter

Stuffed and topped with a spiced cookie blend from Biscoff®

Cookies and Cream

Stuffed and topped with Oreo® cookies

Eggnog

Stuffed with eggnog ganache, topped with nutmeg sprinkle

Gender Reveal- Blue

Boy or girl? Let our Buckeyes reveal the sweetest surprise! Our handcrafted Gender Reveal Buckeyes are a fun and delicious way to share your exciting news with family and friends. Made with our signature creamy peanut butter filling and dipped in rich chocolate, these special Buckeyes feature a hidden pink or blue surprise inside! Want to keep the surprise a secret from yourself, too? Simply drop off your sealed gender reveal envelope at our shop, and we’ll take care of the rest! We’ll create your Gender Reveal Buckeyes with the sweetest pink or blue surprise inside, so you can experience the big reveal too!

Gender Reveal- Pink

Boy or girl? Let our Buckeyes reveal the sweetest surprise! Our handcrafted Gender Reveal Buckeyes are a fun and delicious way to share your exciting news with family and friends. Made with our signature creamy peanut butter filling and dipped in rich chocolate, these special Buckeyes feature a hidden pink or blue surprise inside! Want to keep the surprise a secret from yourself, too? Simply drop off your sealed gender reveal envelope at our shop, and we’ll take care of the rest! We’ll create your Gender Reveal Buckeyes with the sweetest pink or blue surprise inside, so you can experience the big reveal too!

Gingerbread

Stuffed and topped with gingerbread

Hazelnut Cream

Stuffed and topped with Nutella®

Key Lime

Stuffed with key lime ganache and topped with graham cracker crumble

Lemon Up Inspired

Stuffed with lemon cake and topped with crushed lemon cookies

Orange Creamsicle

Stuffed with orange cream cake, topped with a white chocolate chip

Original Cheesecake

Stuffed with plain cheesecake, topped with graham cracker crumble. ft. The Cheesecake Girl

PB&J

Stuffed and topped with red raspberry jelly

Peep Inspired

Stuffed with marshmallow buttercream, topped with marshmallow fluff and sanding sugar

Peppermint Patty

Stuffed with peppermint patty mixture and topped with holiday colored nonpareil sprinkles

Puppy Chow

Stuffed and topped with dessert Chex Mix™

Red Velvet

Stuffed with red velvet cake

S'mores

Stuffed with marshmallow buttercream, sitting atop a graham square and marshmallow fluff, topped with peanut butter cookies

Salted Caramel Pretzel

Features a pretzel, caramel, and sea salt

Samoa™ Cookie Inspired

Stuffed with a caramel coconut mixture, topped with toasted coconut and ganache

Sea Salt Caramel

Stuffed and topped with caramel cream and sea salt flakes

Snickerdoodle Cookie Dough

Stuffed with cinnamon cookie dough, topped with snickerdoodle cookie crumble

Strawberry

Stuffed with strawberry cream, topped with strawberry cookie crumble

Sugar Cookie

Stuffed and topped with sugar cookies and sprinkles

Thin Mint Inspired

Stuffed with a mint mixture, topped with mint cookies

Toffee

Stuffed and topped with Heath® bar toffee

Traditional

Classic peanut butter and chocolate buckeye

Traditional with Birthday Sprinkles

Classic peanut butter and chocolate buckeye topped with rainbow birthday sprinkles

Traditional with Custom Sprinkles

Classic peanut butter and chocolate buckeye topped with your choice of colored sprinkles. Please leave a note in the Notes Section at checkout.

Traditional with Scarlet and Gray Sprinkles

Classic peanut butter and chocolate buckeye topped with Scarlet and Gray sprinkles

Turtle

Stuffed with pecans, topped with crushed pecans and caramel

Vegan Bourbon

Bourbon flavored dough, contains alcohol

Vegan Cookies & Cream

Stuffed and topped with Oreos

Vegan PBJ

Stuffed and topped with red raspberry jelly

Vegan Puppy Chow

Stuffed and topped with dessert Chex Mix

Vegan Traditional

Classic peanut butter and chocolate buckeye

Vegan White Chocolate

Classic vegan buckeye dipped in white chocolate

White Chocolate

Classic buckeye dipped in white chocolate